Northern Arizona University                                                       University Honors Program

Honors 190                                                                               Fall 2003

 

Seminar in Critical Reading and Writing I

Section 2

Class Number 7095

 

Instructor:                                Bruce Fox, Ph.D. Director, Honors Program. Professor of Forest Management                                   

Office Hours:                            Monday-Friday 10:00-11:00am and by appointment.

Class Meeting Time:               MWF 9:10-10:00am. Room 106 Cowden Hall

Phone/Office/e-mail:               523.6636/Room 107 Cowden Hall/ Bruce.Fox@nau.edu

 

Course Prerequisites:

 

Admission to the Honors Program. See also number 1 below, under “Course Requirements.”

 

Course Description:

 

Honors 190 is a reading- and writing-intensive course designed to introduce you to a liberal studies education. An important part of this course is your acquisition of specific skills: close (i.e. critical) reading, effective analytical writing, cogent speaking (effective oral communication), attentive and active listening, and critical thinking. The readings for this class, as well as the tasks required of you, have been carefully chosen and arranged to make possible your attainment and enhancement of these skills, within a learning environment that encourages your understanding and appreciation of the key issues at the heart of a liberal studies education. Your Honors 190 instructors come from a variety of academic disciplines and professions. Your instructors will help you to define and explore these key issues in a manner that reflects their unique training, specialties, and perspectives.

 

Course Orientation and Goals:

 

In this course your readings, writings, and class discussions will address, both broadly as well as specifically, the theme of the human condition, and the ideas and issues arising from this theme: e.g., the nature and function of being human; societies, communities, and communication; morals, ethics, and ethnicities; power; gender; or identity, to name a few. Through your readings and discussions this semester, you will work to clarify these issues, refine your thoughts and attitudes about them, and consider these issues within the context of the university and higher education.

 

By the end of this course, you will:

§         Demonstrate refined capabilities in essential lifelong skills, including close (i.e. critical) reading, effective analytical writing, cogent speaking (effective oral communication), attentive listening, and critical thinking.

§         Recognize the complexities of the human condition from a variety of perspectives, including: literary, historical, cultural, moral, and social.

§         Understand the roles and responsibilities you have as a member of the honors and/or university community and as a citizen of the 21st century.

 

Course Requirements:

 

The following represents minimum requirements common to each section of Honors 190.  All sections have the same writing requirements. The reading requirements amount to approximately 70% of readings common in genre across all sections (although not the same exact texts), with the remaining 30% unique to each individual instructor.  Note also that each individual instructor will provide guidelines for informal writing, formal writing, portfolios, bibliographies, and class participation, and I will provide these to you.

           

1.       HON 190 and HON191 may be taken in any order. (a) If you are enrolled in HON190 as your first freshman Honors course, you must take the English Composition Exam to pass this course.  If you do not pass the English Composition Placement Exam, you must take ENG 205 co-registered with HON191. (b) If you are enrolled in HON 191 as your first freshman Honors course, you must take the English Composition exam to pass this course. If you do not pass the English Composition Placement Exam, you must take ENG 205 co-registered with HON 191.

2.       To emphasize, all sections of HON 190 will read a selection of texts, taken from the groups listed under “Course Texts” (see below). In addition to these readings, I have selected two other texts to help achieve specific learning goals.

3.       You will write a 3-page paper during the first two weeks of classes on the University-wide Freshmen Summer Reading Letters from Yellowstone.

4.       You will write 3 formal, analytical essays (the first 3-7pages, the second and third 5-7 pages each) that explore topics and issues related to your readings and discussions. You will also revise each of these papers through a peer-review process.

5.       You will complete a minimum of 13 pieces of informal writing, each 1 ½ - 3 pages long.

6.       You will complete an annotated bibliography on a topic, book, or issue related to your class readings or discussions, and containing a minimum of 5 secondary sources.

7.       You will submit a collection of informal writing at the end of the semester that consists of 10 of your best revised informal writing assignments, and a 1-2 page “self statement.”

8.       You are expected to participate thoughtfully and intelligently in all class discussions.

9.       You will submit 2 written assignments to the Freshmen Honors Program Assessment website. The first assignment will be your 3-page paper on the Required Summer Reading (see #3 above), and the second assignment will be your best formal essay. Your instructors will clarify this procedure for you.

 

Assessment and Grading:

 

The goals and objectives listed above will be assessed and/or graded in the following manner:

 

1.       15% of total grade: 1 3-7 page formal essay on 1 text/reading.

2.       20% of total grade: 1 5-7 page formal essay on 2 texts/readings.

3.       20% of total grade: 1 5-7 page formal essay on 2 or more texts/readings.

4.       15% of total grade: 1 5-item (minimum) annotated bibliography on a topic related to class readings/discussion.

5.       15% of total grade: participation. This portion of your grade will include some or all of the following: class attendance; active and informed class discussions; active and informed participation in study groups; write-ups of your study group meetings; on-time submission of formal and informal writing assignments; diligent attention to peer reviews of essays; an awareness of and respect for differing opinions; one10-minute book report; submission of writing assignments to the Honors assessment website; attendance at the sophomore/junior/senior Honors Symposium in November, and other options as assigned by your instructor. Individual instructors will specify the requirements for this aspect of your grade.

6.       15% of total grade: a collection of informal writing consisting of a minimum of 10 pieces of informal writing, revised; 1 copy of your best formal essay; and a 1-2 page “Self Statement.”

 

TOTAL: 100%

 

 

Attendance, Academic Dishonesty Policies:

 

Attendance.  Seminars such as this are joint enterprises and it is crucial that we come to speak, to listen, to contribute, and to learn together.  Much of the learning in this class will take place during the scheduled class times as a result of our discussions and various presentations.  Students who learn the most do so, among other reasons, because they participate and involve themselves consistently and earnestly in class discussions with their instructor, guests, and with other students.  These experiences are irreplaceable and impossible to replicate.  Thus, class attendance is of the utmost importance and students who miss class will be penalized.  Therefore, to encourage attendance

 

a student with 4 or more unexcused absences, will have his or her grade

lowered by one letter grade.

 

Academic dishonesty in all forms violates the basic principles of integrity and thus impedes learning. More specifically, academic dishonesty is a form of misconduct subject to disciplinary action under the Student Code of Conduct and includes the following: cheating, fabrication, fraud, facilitating academic dishonesty, and plagiarism. Academic dishonesty, as defined in the Student Handbook, will not be tolerated in this class, and will be handled in the manner prescribed by this handbook.  Read more about University policies at: ww4.nau.edu/stulife/StudentHandbook/TableofContents.htm

 

Course Texts:

·              Summer Reading:

o        Diane Smith, Letters from Yellowstone*

·              Education Readings:

o        Mortimer Adler, "What Is A Liberal Education?" http://www.ditext.com/adler/wle.html

o        Cronon, “Only Connect…” http://www.csun.edu/~hfmgt001/education1.htm

o        Cousins, “How to Make People Smaller Than They Are” http://www.louisville.edu/a-s/students/ssw/Chap2-2.html

o        Bird, “College is a Waste of Time”

o        Postman, “Learning by Story”*

o        Malcolm X, selection from Autobiography of Malcolm X

o        Hirsch, “Cultural Literacy”* http://astro.temple.edu/~sparkss/hirschculture.htm

o        McCarthy, The Groves of Academe (selection)*

·              Greek Classics:

o        Sophocles, Antigone*

o        Sophocles, Oedipus Rex

o        Euripides, Medea*

o        Aeschylus, Agamemnon

o        Aeschylus, Prometheus*  http://classics.mit.edu/Aeschylus/prometheus.html

o        Aristophanes, Peace*  http://classics.mit.edu/Aristophanes/peace.html

o        Aristophanes, The Frogs

o        Aristophanes, The Clouds

o        Plato, (selection)

·              18th Century Satire:

o        Voltaire, Candide*

o        Swift, Gulliver’s Travels

·              Romanticism and the Gothic:

o        Shelley, Frankenstein*

o        Wilde, The Picture of Dorian Gray*

·              Political Writing:

o       Thoreau, Civil Disobedience http://sunsite.berkeley.edu/Literature/Thoreau/CivilDisobedience.html

o        Martin Luther King, “Letter from a Birmingham Jail”  http://www.wmich.edu/politics/mlk/jail.html

·              Existentialism

o        Camus, The Stranger*

·              Environmental Ethics:

o        Leopold, A Sand County Almanac (selection)*

o        Nabhan, Cultures of Habitat (selection)

o        Thoreau, Walden (selection)

·              Writing Instruction

o        Maimon and Peritz, A Writer’s Resource*

·              Memoirs

o        Houston & Houston, Farewell to Manzanar*

o        Robinson, A Single Square Picture*

 

 

NOTE 1:  texts with the * will be used in this section of HON 190

NOTE 2:  some of the materials listed above will be available through Electronic Reserve or through various websites.


 

 

TENTATIVE Course Schedule:

 

 

Week                           Reading Assignments                             Writing Assignments

 

Week 1:                        Required Summer                             Informal Writing #1

8/25                              Reading for Freshmen;

                                    Letters from Yellowstone

                                    Selection from readings

                                    on ethics and education

                                   

Week 2:                        Greek Classics                                               Informal Writing #2

9/1                               Antigone

 

Week 3:                        Medea                                                  Informal Writing #3;

9/8                                                                                           Working Draft of

                                                                                                            Formal Paper #1;

                                                                                                Peer Review                           

 

Week 4:                        18th Century Satire                         Informal Writing #4;

9/15                              Candide                                                Final Draft of Formal

                                                                                                              Paper #1

                                               

Week 5:                        Candide                                                Informal Writing #5

9/22                             

 

Week 6:                        Romanticism and the                          Informal Writing #6

9/29                              Gothic

                                    Prometheus Bound

                                    Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein

 

Week 7:                        Frankenstein                                         Informal Writing #7

10/6                                                                                         

 

Week 8:                        The Picture of Dorian Gray                   Informal Writing #8;

10/13                                                                                        Working Draft of

                                                                                                            Formal Paper #2;

                                                                                                Peer Review

 

Week 9:                        The Picture of Dorian Gray                   Informal Writing #9;

10/20                                                                                        Final Draft of Formal

                                                                                                             Paper #2                                                                               

 

Week 10:                      Memoirs                                              Informal Writing #10

10/27                            Farewell to Manzanar

 

 

Week 11:                      A Single Square Picture                          Informal Writing #11

11/3                             

 

Week 12:                      Existentialism                                     Informal Writing #12;

11/10                            Peace

                                    Camus, The Stranger                            

                                                                                                           

 

Week 13:                      Existentialism                                     Working Draft of Formal

11/17                            The Stranger                                                              Paper #3;

                                                                                                Peer Review                                                                                                  Review

 

Week 14:                      Environmental Ethics                           Informal #13

                                                                                                Final Draft of Formal Paper

11/24                            Sand County Almanac                                                #3 with Bibliography                 

                                                                                                            due                                                                    

 

Week 15:                      Educational Readings                         Informal #14

12/1                              Postman, Hirsch                      

 

 

 

 

HON 190 TENTATIVE Formal and Informal Writing Assignments

 

Informal #1            journey through writing

 

Informal #2            Letters from Yellowstone

 

Informal #3            Ethics

 

Formal #1            your favorite work of fiction or non-fiction…and why (3-5pp)

 

Informal #4            TBA

 

Informal #5            Medea and Antigone:  the nature of hubris

 

Informal #6            Candide

 

Informal #7            Frankenstein

 

Informal #8            Frankenstein texts & contexts (presentation)

 

Formal #2          A comparison of texts, e.g., Frankenstein & Prometheus Bound, or Frankenstein & Antigone, or Candide & Peace (5-7 pages)

 

Informal #9            Picture of Dorian Gray

 

Informal #10            TBA

 

Informal #11            Manzanar/Single Square Picture

 

Bibliography            Annotations for final paper

 

Formal #3          TBA

 

Informal #12            Stranger

 

Informal #13            Environmental ethics/a special place

 

Informal #14            Educational readings