Close This Window

Tribal Air Quality Management - Policy, Regulations, and Permitting Information

REGULATIONS, CODES, AND ORDINANCES

What types of regulations, codes or ordinances can the tribe develop to protect their air resources?

One way for tribes to manage their air resources and prevent air pollution is through regulating polluting industries and activities on tribal lands. This can include developing:

Smoke Management Plans

Open Burning Regulations

Emission Release Requirements

Pollution Prevention Procedural Requirements

When developing regulations to control air pollution on tribal lands, tribes should keep in mind the importance of enforcing the proposed regulations. Capability to enforce compliance with regulations must be incorporated into federally approved tribal air programs that use regulatory controls for pollution. In addition to implementing pollution control regulations, tribes can:

Pursue redesignation of their airshed (to Class I)

Enter into Tribal Environmental Agreements (TEAs) with the EPA

Collaborate with regional, state and local air pollution control agencies to address issues of pollution transport

GENERAL EXTERNAL LINKS:

ABA Article "Environmental Regulations on Indian Lands"

Contains full text of the article by L.H. Slade and W.E. Stern. Topics include: tribal jurisdiction, federal delegation, water quality, air quality, drinking water, and related issues.

Tribal Environmental Law

Contains links and information on resources about tribal environmental laws and regulations, as well as links around the rest of the site, which focuses on tribal codes and constitutions. Topics include: tribal environmental websites, federal-tribal websites, FAQs, tribal environmental codes (from EnviroText website), and more.

Native Americans and the Environment

Contains links to navigate through documents and other resources in their clearinghouse, as well as tribal case studies, relevant Internet links, and a searchable database of resources. Topics include: Agriculture and ranching, culture and history, energy, environmental education, environmental justice, forestry, fishing, treaty rights, toxic and nuclear waste, and other issues and resources.

ELIGIBILITY DETERMINATION (TAS)

USEPA AIEO TAS Information

Contains a summary of the regulations and issues surrounding TAS determination, and changes to the existing process, plus links to the rest of the EPA site. Topics include: TAS with respect to the CAA, CWA, and SDWA.

TIP

USEPA TribalAir TIP Explanation

Contains summary information on tribal authority to develop TIPs, plus links to comments on the Explanation, and links to the rest of the TribalAir and EPA pages. Topics include: TIPs, TAR, SIPs, modular approach, severable elements of a TIP, plus example TIPs for different cases.

USEPA TIP Information

Contains information on, and a link to downloading the Draft Tribal Implementation Plan guidance. Topics include: TIP.

COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT

USEPA National Compliance Assistance Clearinghouse (NCAC)

Contains links to predefined and user-defined searches, EPA related sites, discussion forums, news, and other sites. Search tabs branch out into many topics related to compliance. For example: click on the Environmental Focus tab to find information about air quality, or the Industry and Government tab to locate fact sheets and other documents regarding industry-related compliance issues. Topics include: environmental compliance and enforcement.

REDESIGNATION

Yavapai-Apache Class I Redesignation

Contains overview information and links to explanatory documents and the full text of the notice of approval, plus links to the rest of the EPA site. Topics include: NAAQS, PSD, Class I redesignation, map of Class I areas in Arizona, map of Tribal lands in Arizona, Federal Register notice approving redesignation, Federal Register notice of dispute resolution.

NCSE Report on Promulgating NAAQS

Contains a report on promulgating NAAQS (re)designations. Topics include: NAAQS (re)designation, administrative rule-making, judicial review, NAAQS regulatory timeline, and other related topics.

TEAs

Draft Tribal Environmental Agreement

Contains sample documents for guidance to tribes developing TEAs with the EPA. Topics include: TEA.

USEPA TEA Template

Contains text of memorandum from the AIEO Director, plus a draft Tribal Environmental Agreement Template. Topics include: Tribal Environmental Agreements (TEAs), action plans, planning and budget cycles, and more.

How does the tribe have authority to enforce regulations?

The Tribal Authority Rule (TAR) outlines specifics about tribal authority to implement and enforce regulations for controlling air pollution within reservation boundaries.

Although a federal tribal air program is not necessary for the development, implementation, and enforcement of regulatory controls on air pollution, without one, the regulations cannot be enforced in federal courts, and cannot apply over non-tribally owned lands (the regulations would only apply to the same jurisdictions as other tribal laws and regulations).

Tribes should have the capacity (human and financial resources) and capability (legal resources) to enforce the regulations and carry out the consequences of noncompliance.

GENERAL EXTERNAL LINKS:

ABA Article "Environmental Regulations on Indian Lands"

Contains full text of the article by L.H. Slade and W.E. Stern. Topics include: tribal jurisdiction, federal delegation, water quality, air quality, drinking water, and related issues.

Tribal Environmental Law

Contains links and information on resources about tribal environmental laws and regulations, as well as links around the rest of the site, which focuses on tribal codes and constitutions. Topics include: tribal environmental websites, federal-tribal websites, FAQs, tribal environmental codes (from EnviroText website), and more.

TAR

USEPA TribalAir TAR Information

Contains general information, and links to the TAR, a TAR fact sheet, and the TAR proposal, as well as links to other EPA sites. Topics include: the TAR, permitting in Indian Country, CAA amendments, etc.

ELIGIBILITY DETERMINATION (TAS)

USEPA AIEO TAS Information

Contains a summary of the regulations and issues surrounding TAS determination, and changes to the existing process, plus links to the rest of the EPA site. Topics include: TAS with respect to the CAA, CWA, and SDWA.

TIPs

USEPA TribalAir TIP Explanation

Contains summary information on tribal authority to develop TIPs, plus links to comments on the Explanation, and links to the rest of the TribalAir and EPA pages. Topics include: TIPs, TAR, SIPs, modular approach, severable elements of a TIP, plus example TIPs for different cases.

USEPA TIP Information

Contains information on, and a link to downloading the Draft Tribal Implementation Plan guidance. Topics include: TIP.

COMPLIANCE AND ENFORCEMENT

USEPA National Compliance Assistance Clearinghouse (NCAC)

Contains links to predefined and user-defined searches, EPA related sites, discussion forums, news, and other sites. Search tabs branch out into many topics related to compliance. For example: click on the Environmental Focus tab to find information about air quality, or the Industry and Government tab to locate fact sheets and other documents regarding industry-related compliance issues. Topics include: environmental compliance and enforcement.

SOURCE PERMITTING

What is a stationary source permit?

Major stationary sources of pollution are permitted by state, local and tribal authorities. These permits fall under one of two categories: operating permits and construction permits. Operating permits for major polluting sources are also called Title V permits, whereas permits for construction or reconstruction fall under the New Source Review (NSR) and Prevention of Significant Deterioration (PSD) programs.

GENERAL PERMITTING INFORMATION:

USEPA Operating Permits Program

Contains an overview of operating permits, and links to Title V, the CAA, 40 CFR part 70, FAQs, and the rest of the EPA site. Topics include: Title V, operating permits, CAA, permitting in Indian country, enforcement, and more.

USEPA Frequently Asked Questions About Air Permits

Contains list of FAQs and links to the answers, plus links to the rest of the EPA site. Topics include: construction and operating permits.

TITLE IV

USEPA Title IV (Acid Deposition) Information

Contains links to relevant Federal Register documents, other reports and memos, and a fact sheet, plus links to the rest of the EPA site. Topics include: acid deposition, permitting sources of pollution that contribute to acid rain, and more.

TITLE V

NYPIRG Title V Information

Contains links to news, publications and resources, contact information, petitions and comment letters, and related Title V websites. Topics include: Title V, CAA, and more.

USEPA Title V Policy and Guidance Database

Contains information on, and links to, downloading the Database, or to using it online, plus links to the rest of the EPA site. Topics include: Title V. There are some documents relating to Title V in Indian Country.

USEPA Part 71 Final Rule - 122K pdf

Contains full text of the rule. Topics include: Title V, permits, and more.

USEPA Forms for Part 71 Permits

Contains general information on form use, and links to download individual forms, plus links to the rest of the EPA site. Topics include: Title V, permits, compliance, emissions, and more.

NEW SOURCE REVIEW AND PREVENTION OF SIGNIFICANT DETERIORATION

USEPA New Source Review Information

Contains links to information on EPA's NSR program, program updates, the NSR & PSD Database, contacts, and links to the rest of the EPA site. Topics include: NSR, permitting, and more.

NSR & PSD Policy and Guidance Database

Contains information on the database, and links and instructions for using or downloading it, plus links to the rest of the Region 7 site. Topics include: New Source Review (NSR) and Prevention of Significant Deterioration (PSD).

How does the tribe know if source permitting should be conducted on the reservation?

Tribes should assess the air quality on tribal lands on a case-by-case basis, as each reservation will have different kinds of sources. It is also important to remember that the EPA takes over the regulation of major sources in Indian Country if the tribe does not enforce the minimum standards set forth in federal regulations.

GENERAL EXTERNAL LINKS:

USEPA Operating Permits Program

Contains an overview of operating permits, and links to Title V, the CAA, 40 CFR part 70, FAQs, and the rest of the EPA site. Topics include: Title V, operating permits, CAA, permitting in Indian country, enforcement, and more.

USEPA Frequently Asked Questions About Air Permits

Contains list of FAQs and links to the answers, plus links to the rest of the EPA site. Topics include: construction and operating permits.

USEPA New Source Review Information

Contains links to information on EPA's NSR program, program updates, the NSR & PSD Database, contacts, and links to the rest of the EPA site. Topics include: NSR, permitting, and more.

How can tribes implement and enforce major and minor source permits?

Tribal authority to regulate air pollution on tribal lands is an inherent right of tribal sovereignty. Tribes do not need a federally enforceable air program in order to regulate or permit sources of pollution, but having a federally enforceable program extends tribal regulatory jurisdiction to all lands within the exterior boundaries of a reservation, and any other tribally owned lands.

In order to grant operating and construction permits to sources in Indian Country, but outside tribally owned lands, tribes must receive eligibility determination from the EPA under the CAA, and must have an approved Tribal Implementation Plan

GENERAL EXTERNAL LINKS:

USEPA Operating Permits Program

Contains an overview of operating permits, and links to Title V, the CAA, 40 CFR part 70, FAQs, and the rest of the EPA site. Topics include: Title V, operating permits, CAA, permitting in Indian country, enforcement, and more.

USEPA New Source Review Information

Contains links to information on EPA's NSR program, program updates, the NSR & PSD Database, contacts, and links to the rest of the EPA site. Topics include: NSR, permitting, and more.

ELIGIBILITY DETERMINATION or TREATMENT AS A STATE (TAS)

What is eligibility or Treatment as a State (TAS) determination?

Eligibility determination, also called "Treatment as a State" (TAS) was developed by the EPA for purposes of affording tribes the authorization to manage an air (or water) quality program in a manner similar to the way a state manages its program. Under the CAA, formal recognition of eligibility (or TAS), can be achieved by tribes that meet the following requirements:

Tribe is federally recognized

Tribe has a governing body that has substantial governing powers and duties

Tribe intends to manage and protect air quality within the exterior boundaries of the reservation

Tribe has the capability to implement CAA programs within the exterior boundaries of the reservation (this is determined case-by-case by the EPA Regional Administrator, and involves a tribe’s capacity to undertake the activities of proposed actions, as well as a land base over which to exercise jurisdiction for the proposed activities)

By acquiring eligibility determination, tribes can:

Become eligible for reduced match funding (5%-10%) under the CAA Section 105 grant program

Develop a Tribal Implementation Plan (TIP)

Implement federally enforceable regulations regarding air quality on tribal lands

Participate in new source review and operating permit programs for major on-reservation sources

GENERAL EXTERNAL LINKS:

USEPA AIEO TAS Information

Contains a summary of the regulations and issues surrounding TAS determination, and changes to the existing process, plus links to the rest of the EPA site. Topics include: TAS with respect to the CAA, CWA, and SDWA.

NTEC - Tribal Air Organization

Contains listing of the Table of Contents and links to those sections of the document, as well as links to the rest of the NTEC site. Topics include: TAR, jurisdiction, regional haze, WRAP, attainment, functions and actions of a tribal air quality organization (or program).

TRIBAL IMPLEMENTATION PLANS (TIPs)

What is a Tribal Implementation Plan (TIP)?

A Tribal Implementation Plan (TIP) is the tribal equivalent to a State Implementation Plan (SIP). TIPs are used for implementing provisions of the Clean Air Act (CAA), such as regulating NAAQS-related pollution activities. Any federally recognized tribe that has received an eligibility determination under the CAA can develop a TIP.

GENERAL EXTERNAL LINKS:

USEPA TIP Information

Contains information on, and a link to downloading the Draft Tribal Implementation Plan guidance. Topics include: TIP.

USEPA TribalAir TIP Explanation

Contains summary information on tribal authority to develop TIPs, plus links to comments on the Explanation, and links to the rest of the TribalAir and EPA pages. Topics include: TIPs, TAR, SIPs, modular approach, severable elements of a TIP, plus example TIPs for different cases.



Close This Window

						


Last updated: March 20, 2007